Murray’s Substack

Murray’s Substack

Welcome, New Year Resolutioners

How to Actually Keep Your Gym Resolution (And Not Be Gone by February)

Murray Hill Guy's avatar
Murray Hill Guy
Dec 29, 2025
∙ Paid

Every January, the gym fills up. Low key an annoying time for the regulars, but I do respect new people trying to fix themselves.

The wave of new people with fancy outfits, sneakers, etc…

And every February (sometimes even sooner)… it’s gone.

Not because people are lazy, but because most people attack the gym with emotion instead of structure.

Motivation gets you through week one.
Systems are what keep you there all year.

Here’s how to actually stay.


Rule #1: Stop Trying to “Get in Shape”

This is where almost everyone fails.

“Get in shape” is vague.
Vague goals don’t survive discomfort.

Your goal for the first 30 days is not:

  • fat loss

  • abs

  • PRs

  • a physical transformation

Your only job is showing up on schedule even when nothing happens.

If you leave the gym thinking, “that didn’t even feel like much” good.
That’s how habits form.


Rule #2: Frequency Beats Intensity (Every Time)

January resolutioners go way too hard. People want to see results QUICK and it doesn’t work like that.

They:

  • train 5–6 days a week

  • destroy their legs

  • can’t walk

  • miss workouts

  • disappear

Instead:

  • 3 days per week

  • same days

  • same time

  • boring consistency

Your plan should work on your worst week, not your best one.


Rule #3: Never Walk Into the Gym Without a Plan

Winging workouts is how people wander… and quit.

You need:

  • exercises written down

  • order decided

  • reps set

Decision fatigue kills consistency.

If you have to think too much, you’ll start negotiating with yourself.
Negotiation is the beginning of the end.


Rule #4: Leave the Gym Feeling Like You Could’ve Done More

This sounds wrong. It’s not.

People quit when:

  • every workout feels like a test

  • soreness becomes punishment

  • recovery becomes miserable

You should walk out thinking:

“I could do this again tomorrow if I had to.”

That feeling keeps you coming back.


Rule #5: Track One Thing (Not Everything)

You don’t need:

  • macro spreadsheets

  • body fat scans

  • daily scale panic

  • 12 different metrics

Pick one:

  • weights going up

  • reps improving

  • consistency streak

Visible progress beats perfect tracking.


If you’ve ever started strong and disappeared by February this is the part that actually fixes that.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Murray Hill Guy.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Murray Hill Guy · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture